People talk
Our Guestbook
“ The food is absolutely amazing. However, it's expensive! I do love their strombolis and salads very very fresh!!! I wish it just didn't cost so much, lol! ”
“ I have been a customer for years. Love pizza, chicken Bella and garlic knots. Thanks for the good food ”
“ Best pizza in massena! True Italian pizza with a nice thin hard crust. The meat lovers can be a little greasy but that's some people's taste! I prefer the basic cheese pizza, I get a small pizza for lunch for my wife and I, can't beat it for 12 bucks. ”
“ Outstanding pizza! Friendly staff!!! The broccoli pizza is the best!! Crust is cooked to perfection! Price is reasonable! Would definitely recommend!!! ”
“ Tasty chicken wings, lots of different flavors! Yummy Stromboli's. Service was great! ”
“ Food is always great! Servers are amazing. Seating comfortable and clean. Very Disappointed that they are charging 3% extra to your bill if you pay with a credit card. Not sure if we will return, we have been loyal customers for over 10 years. ”
“ The Hawaiian Stromboli is FIRE! I've had it twice now and would travel the 1.5 hour drive to have it again! What a diamond in the rough that is Massena. Highly recommend. ”
“ I'm from New York and moved to Florida. I've had a lot of different pizza here in Florida so far, but it's nice to just enjoy a regular cheese slice and tastes like it's actually from New York. Deff would eat at this food truck again. ”
“ Stopped for lunch today. Grabbed a Meatball Sub and Greek Pizza. Food as always was fantastic. The young lady waiting our table was pretty awesome too. These folks never disappoint. ”
“ Ordered take out from Italian Affair tonight - this restaurant is by far the most consistent pizza restaurant in town and definitely first or second for the quality of their products. Tonight's order was a large Italian Stromboli and an antipasto. The Stromboli is our favorite type - salami, ham and pepperoni with sauce and mozzarella. Large enough to feed four and done perfect. The antipasto was good - crisp lettuce, black olives, onions, tomatoes and salami and provolone florets and a nice dollop of tuna in the middle. ”
Menu
MOZZARELLA STICKS
PASTA LA VISTA
$15.45SPINACH
HAM
CHICKEN
$9.75
About
An Italian Affair
Welcome to An Italian Affair, a delightful gem nestled in the heart of Massena, NY. If you're in search of authentic Italian cuisine, this eatery delivers a slice of Italy right to your plate. With a diverse menu centered around pizza, their offerings go beyond typical fare, ensuring an experience that’s both memorable and satisfying.
Located at 339 E Orvis St, An Italian Affair provides a vibrant and casual dining atmosphere, perfect for families and groups alike. It’s not just about the food; it's about the experience. The establishment is wheelchair accessible and accommodates both indoor and outdoor seating, making it a comfortable choice regardless of your party size.
- Delivery & Takeout: Enjoy your favorite Italian dishes from the comfort of your home.
- Reservations: Planning a special night out? Make a reservation for a hassle-free experience.
- Catering: Perfect for gatherings, weddings, or corporate events.
- Casual Dress: Whether you're dressed up or in relaxed attire, you’ll fit right in.
- Party Friendly: Ideal for larger groups and families, confirmed by enthusiastic reviews from returning customers who crave the pizza and garlic knots.
The star of An Italian Affair is undoubtedly their pizzas, which have received rave reviews. Customers like Gary W. appreciate the thin, crispy crust, noting that each bite is a true Italian experience. For those who prefer a lighter fare, options like the broccoli pizza capture the fresh flavors of Italy, according to Kendra M., who commends the perfectly cooked crust.
Not to overlook the unique combinations, the menu showcases items like their popular strombolis and salads, which Lori T. praises for their freshness despite a slightly premium price tag. And if you’re in the mood for something crispy, don’t miss their flavorful chicken wings highlighted by Kelly J. as a crowd-pleaser.
Overall, An Italian Affair combines a tourist-friendly atmosphere with delicious, bona fide Italian cuisine that promises to impress. Whether you seek a quiet dinner, an active happy hour, or a relaxed family meal, this place is tailored for every occasion. The friendly staff ensures that your experience is both personal and enjoyable, making every visit a little affair to remember.
Next time you're in Massena, don’t miss out on what may just become your new favorite Italian spot!
Book a table